Skip to content
The American Political Almanac
RECONSTRUCTION & THE GILDED AGETHE SYSTEM OF 1896THE NEW DEAL ORDERTHE LONG REALIGNMENTPOLARIZED ERARR1876RRD1888RDRRR1908RDDRR1928RDDDD1948DRRDD1968RRDRR1988RDDRR2008DDRD2024R

The Nation Decides

Electoral votes, the popular vote, and how every state moved
Samuel J. Tilden
Democrat
Samuel J. Tilden
184
Electoral votes
50.9% · 4,301,703
President · Reconstruction & the Gilded Age

1876

Hayes def. Tilden, 185–184
won the presidency, lost the popular votevote totals summed from county returns
✓ Won
Rutherford B. Hayes
Republican
Rutherford B. Hayes
185
Electoral votes
47.9% · 4,042,920
Electoral college — 185 to win (369 electors)184 D · 185 R
Popular vote50.9% · 47.9% · other 1.2% · margin D+3.0

8,433,423 votes counted (summed from counties)

Electoral map — one tile per state · coloured by county-summed popular vote
R+40D+40third party won

Per-state electoral vote detail is staged from 1976; earlier years show the national college in the bar above, and states are coloured by their county-summed popular vote.

The swing from last time
Change in each state’s margin since 1872 · ← toward Republicans · toward Democrats →

The Map Beneath the Map

Three thousand counties, and the demography of the divide

Every county that cast a ballot, shaded by its margin. Hover any county to read it; click to open its 156-year profile. Scrub the timeline above and the map redraws in place. Vote counts exist for all forty elections; the demographic lenses begin in 2000.

County margin

Drawing three thousand counties…

R+40D+40no returns

Who voted for whom? The survey record begins with the 1948 ANES — there is no comparable individual-level account of the 1876 electorate.

Notes on this election

  • Disputed returns in FL, LA, SC, and OR were settled by the Electoral Commission; the Compromise of 1877 ended Reconstruction. Tilden won the popular vote by 3 points — the largest PV margin ever for an EC loser.